Top 10 Cozy Mystery Books to Read by the Fire This Fall
This post is all about the hottest Cozy Mystery Books
Hi bestie!
The weather is cooling down, the leaves are crunching underfoot, and you know what that means—cozy mystery season is officially here! There’s something about the crisp autumn air that makes you want to curl up by the fire with a cup of tea (or hot chocolate, because, why not?!) and get lost in a mystery. And when I say “get lost,” I mean sink into the mystery so deep you’re solving crimes right alongside our plucky protagonist— probably while also wondering if you should have been a detective in another life.
Now, let’s talk about what you really need: the perfect lineup of cozy mystery books that are going to have you flipping pages faster than your favorite fall sweater flies off the shelf during a sale. And don’t worry, I’ve got just the list for you, with punny commentary and all the best vibes to carry you through the season. So grab your comfiest blanket, light that pumpkin spice candle, and let’s dive into the Top 10 Cozy Mystery Books to Read by the Fire This Fall!
SAVE THIS PIN
This post may contain affiliate links for products and services I recommend. If you make a purchase through these links, at no additional cost to you, I will earn a small commission. Read the full disclosure here. All photo credits to the original owner.
1. The Thursday Murder Club by Richard Osman
Grab your magnifying glass and cozy slippers, because this quirky group of retirees in a retirement village solves cold cases like nobody’s business. With clever twists and lovable characters, it’s like spending time with your witty grandparents—if your grandparents happened to be amateur sleuths solving murders over tea and biscuits. Trust me, you’ll be hooked faster than you can say “detective duo.”
2. A Deadly Inside Scoop by Abby Collette
What’s better than a cozy mystery? A cozy mystery set in an ice cream shop! This one serves up more than just a whodunit, bestie—it comes with sprinkles of humor and sweet moments that will leave you craving both answers and dessert. And don’t worry, it’s low-calorie, except for the plot twists, those are rich!
3. Arsenic and Adobo by Mia P. Manansala
Not only does this one serve up some culinary delights, but it’s also got a side of murder. If you love food (who doesn’t?), this book will have you both laughing and gasping as Lila Macapagal tries to solve the murder that happened at her family’s Filipino restaurant. Warning: you will be hungry while reading this, so stock up on snacks, bestie!
4. The No. 1 Ladies Detective Agency by Alexander McCall Smith
Travel to Botswana with the ever-charming Precious Ramotswe, the country’s first female detective, as she solves mysteries with grace, wisdom, and just a sprinkle of sass. It’s like a warm hug in book form—perfect for those cozy evenings when you want a slow-burn mystery with lots of heart. Prepare for major “aww” moments between clues!
5. Murder at the Vicarage by Agatha Christie
Is it even a cozy mystery list if Queen Agatha Christie isn’t on it? Miss Marple is the original cozy mystery heroine, and she solves this church-side crime with her signature wit and a cup of tea in hand. It’s classic, it’s cozy, and it’s as comforting as finding that perfect fall scarf you forgot you had. Seriously, you’ll want to curl up with this one and never leave.
6. Death by Dumpling by Vivien Chien
A cozy mystery with dumplings? Sign me up! Lana Lee is the heroine you’ll want to grab a drink with—when she’s not solving murders, of course. Set in a family-owned restaurant in Cleveland’s Chinatown, this one gives you all the feel-good vibes while keeping you guessing until the last page. I mean, who can focus on murder with a plate of dumplings in front of them?
7. The Sweetness at the Bottom of the Pie by Alan Bradley
Flavia de Luce, our 11-year-old detective and chemistry whiz, will absolutely charm your socks off. Set in a 1950s English village, this is a cozy mystery with a bit of spunk and a dash of poison—literally. You’ll find yourself cheering for Flavia while she uncovers clues (and possibly dangerous chemicals). It’s like baking a pie, but with more deadly consequences!
8. The Bookish Life of Nina Hill by Abbi Waxman
What’s more cozy than a book about a bookish protagonist solving life’s little mysteries? Nina Hill is a quiet bookworm with a life that’s as organized as her bookshelf—until an unexpected family member turns her world upside down. While not your traditional whodunit, this cozy tale offers delightful twists, relatable humor, and plenty of charm. Because, bestie, solving life’s mysteries is just as important as solving murders, am I right?
9. A Spell for Trouble by Esme Addison
Calling all magical mystery lovers! This book blends cozy mystery with a sprinkle of magic as Alexandra Daniels discovers her family’s witchy powers in a charming coastal town. It’s perfect for fans of both the paranormal and the puzzling, and it’s got enough spells and suspects to keep you enchanted until the very end. It’s like Hocus Pocus, but with more murder!
10. The Windsor Knot by S.J. Bennett
Ever wondered what it would be like if the Queen of England herself solved crimes? Wonder no more, because this cozy mystery features Queen Elizabeth II taking on the role of detective when a murder occurs at Windsor Castle. It’s regal, witty, and deliciously British—an absolute must-read for royal enthusiasts and mystery lovers alike. Put on your best tea-drinking outfit for this one!
Wow! Can we talk about how your fall reading list just got a MAJOR upgrade? These books are perfect for getting cozy, solving crimes (fictional ones, of course), and sipping your favorite autumn beverage while you dive deep into the world of amateur sleuths, witches, foodies, and queens. Whether you’re looking for a laugh, a gasp, or just a really good mystery to keep you up all night, these cozy reads are going to give you all the fall feels.
And if you’ve already read some of these, let me know in the comments! I need to know which mystery sleuth we’re all obsessed with this season. But before you go, make sure you subscribe to The Catalog by Celine! You won’t want to miss any more bookish recommendations, reading tips, or cozy mysteries to keep you entertained all year long. Trust me, we’ve got a lot of fun to look forward to, bestie.
Happy reading and mystery solving!
Cozy Mystery Books:
What do you think about these books? Which one are you interested in reading first? Let us know your thoughts in the comment section below. Also, follow our storefront on Instagram to shop our chic, stylish and comfy pieces. We cater to all things Fashion & Beauty related just for you!
A Little More About Our Blog?
The Catalog by Celine is a Fashion & Fiction Blog for anyone who loves fashion, beauty, & books. We aim at inspiring you to look and feel like the best version of yourself. Empowering and providing you with our latest fashion finds, inspo, tips, as well as helping you source the perfect novel. Enjoy reading? Check out some of our free books available on our site right here!
Discover more from The Catalog
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
